Fun Home called ‘Pornographic’ in South Carolina

twitter Fun Home called Pornographic in South Carolina5facebook Fun Home called Pornographic in South Carolina0google Fun Home called Pornographic in South Carolina0pinterest Fun Home called Pornographic in South Carolina0tumblr Fun Home called Pornographic in South Carolinareddit Fun Home called Pornographic in South Carolina0stumbleupon Fun Home called Pornographic in South Carolina0email Fun Home called Pornographic in South Carolina

201307301154 Fun Home called Pornographic in South Carolina
A South Carolina watchdog group has criticized the College of Charleston (CofC) in Charleston, South Carolina for choosing Alison Bechdel’s award-winning FUN HOME as recommended reading for freshmen. The book was chosen as a book for freshmen to read before orientation as a sort of college “ice breaker” but the Palmetto Family Council has labeled the book “pornographic” and protested its purchase at a publicly funded university. According to an ABC story:

“If this book were a magazine it would be wrapped in brown paper,” said Oran Smith, director of Palmetto Family Council. “We reviewed every book assigned in SC this year. Many were provocative. This one is pornographic. Not a wise choice for 18-year-olds at a taxpayer-supported college.”


FUN HOME is one of the most lauded graphic novels of the last decade; it does contain some male nudity and scenes of lesbian sex, but only a few panels each. This is not the first time it’s been challenged, as in 2006 a Missouri woman tried to have it and BLANKETS removed from a library.

The CofC has stood by its decision; a student’s reaction to the book later in the ABC report reveals what we knew all along: nothing sells like controversy.

“I read the first 20 pages so far. I’m not too deep into it, but so far it’s pretty good,” said Hassam Solano’Morel, an upcoming freshman. “Actually the fact that it was controversial has actually put me on to reading it because I do like reading things like that and I know that some people especially have a really closed mind and they need to read stuff like that to really expand their thought about what is going on in the world and real situations in life.”


You can read more of the Palmetto Family Council’s thoughts on the book here. Perhaps you can participate in the comments.

Comments

  1. Charles Ranier says:

    I make it a personal point of pride never to accept book recommendations from someone named “Oran”

  2. They’re screening comments there, but not on the Facebook page — at least not yet: https://www.facebook.com/palmettofamily?ref=stream&hc_location=stream

  3. george says:

    I checked it out of a public library in Tennessee. Not aware of any attacks in this neck of the woods, as we say down South.

  4. Please do NOT comment on anything these con men create. They thrive on drumming up fake controversy. You never feed the trolls.

    I mean, what can contributing to this possibly achieve? Either they’re delusional enough to mistake a book that references Proust, James Joyce and Greek mythology as “pornography”, or they’re dishonest enough to get headlines declaring it so. Your keyboard only has so many taps in its lifespan. Don’t waste them.

Speak Your Mind

*